ENVIRONMENT

Trump’s Alcatraz reopening plan draws expert warnings

July 18th, 2025

Former acting director of the Federal Bureau of Prisons Hugh Hurwitz says reviving and reopening Alcatraz, the infamous California prison off the coast of San Francisco, would be a massive undertaking. President Donald Trump has repeatedly expressed strong interest in reopening the prison.

Hurwitz raised several concerns on “NewsNation Now” with Alex Caprariello about feasibility, including outdated infrastructure, the island’s remote location and size and the potentially high cost of construction — factors that would delay the project.

When asked directly how long it would take, Hurwitz said it would take “years” to complete.

“Renovating the facility is not even an option; they’re gonna have to completely tear it down and rebuild a new building from scratch,” Hurwitz said.

The island spans a mere 22 acres, tiny compared to recent federal prison projects.

“The Bureau of Prisons right now is in plans to build another prison in Kentucky that’s 500 acres,” Hurwitz added.

Trump announced his plans for the island back in May.

Surfshark AntiVirus

“The reopening of ALCATRAZ will serve as a symbol of Law, Order, and JUSTICE.” Trump posted on social media.

Hurwitz acknowledged the president is right about the prison’s “mystique” but pointed out the U.S. already has a maximum-security facility for the most dangerous inmates: ADX Florence in Colorado, where prisoners are locked down 23 hours a day.

“They already have that symbol of law and order, if that’s what the president is looking for,” Hurwitz said.

Attorney General Pam Bondi and Interior Secretary Doug Burgum visited the island Thursday. Burgum made an announcement on social media following the visit.

“Spent the day on Alcatraz Island, a (National Park Service) site, to start the work to renovate and reopen the site to house the most dangerous criminals and illegals. This administration is restoring safety, justice, and order to our streets,” Burgum said

Alcatraz has been closed since 1963.

Curated By

Sarah Jenkins
Police Officer | Police Department Public Information Officer | Investigative Reporter/Crime Correspondent
Sarah Jenkins brings two decades of street experience to her reporting, offering blunt, no-nonsense perspectives from real police work. Her true crime and local governance coverage cuts through political posturing and academic theory to focus on what actually happens in communities. Known for critiquing ivory tower thinking, she prioritizes dogged investigation and common-sense analysis over pretty theories that don't hold up in the real world. Her cynicism reflects hard-earned wisdom from seeing how systems actually work. Readers trust her straight talk from someone who's experienced the messy truth of urban life firsthand. "Twenty years on the force taught me that the truth is rarely simple, but it's always worth fighting for."

Suggested Reading

Breaking the Rock: The Great Escape from Alcatraz

Breaking the Rock: The Great Escape from Alcatraz by Jolene Babyak is a meticulously researched nonfiction account of the infamous 1962 escape attempt from Alcatraz Federal Penitentiary, focusing on the intricate planning and execution by four inmates—Frank Morris, brothers John and Clarence Anglin,...

Alcatraz: The Surprising History of America's Most Notorious Prison

The federal prison on Alcatraz Island in the chilly waters of California’s San Francisco Bay housed some of America’s most difficult and dangerous prisoners during its years of operation from 1934 to 1963. Among those who served time at the maximum-security facility were the notorious gangster Al “S...

Eyewitness on Alcatraz: Escapes Prisoners And Families On The Rock

Eyewitness on Alcatraz: Escapes, Prisoners, and Families on The Rock by Jolene Babyak offers a unique, anecdotal social history of Alcatraz Island, focusing on the lived experiences of the guards, their families, and the prisoners who inhabited this infamous federal penitentiary. Published in 1988 b...

We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By continuing to browse, you accept our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.