POLITICS

Will Blue State Refugees Ruin Red States?

December 29th, 2020

State-imposed lockdowns in California and other “blue” states have accelerated the already sizeable exodus of businesses and residents from their states. Texas, where I live and teach, has been among the main beneficiaries.

Each year since 2015, 100,000 more Californians have packed their bags for Arizona, Idaho, Texas, Utah, and other less restrictive, lower-tax, business-friendly states than have arrived in the Golden State. The same is happening on the East Coast, where thousands of former New York and New Jersey residents and business owners have fled to the Carolinas, Georgia, Florida, and other more hospitable and affordable states. But many Carolinians, Floridians, and Texans are worried that blue-state migrants could change their states — and not for the better. They shouldn’t be.

For example, Oracle Corporation, the giant software and technology company, recently announced that it plans to move its headquarters from Redwood City, California, in the heart of Silicon Valley, to Austin, Texas. The announcement came just days after Hewlett Packard Enterprise, another leading technology firm, announced it was moving its headquarters from San Jose, California, to Houston. Similarly, Tesla, the electric vehicle manufacturer, whose sister company SpaceX (Space Exploration Technologies Corporation) already has a major presence in Texas, chose Texas over California for its next big factory.

When these companies move, so do many of their employees. U-Haul rental rates indicate the lopsided nature of the interstate migration. A 26-foot U-Haul truck costs $5,649 to pick up in San Francisco and drop off in Houston. If you’re moving in the reverse direction, that same truck rental costs only $1,712.

Alison Training Health

The prices reflect the fact that demand for trucks exiting California is far greater than the demand for trucks headed there.

On the East Coast the story is similar. In the third quarter (July to September) alone, according to the real-estate brokerage firm Redfin, New York state suffered a net exodus of approximately 47,000 residents.

While many of those moving from California, New York, and other states whose political leaders seem to take pleasure restricting our individual and economic freedoms, many red-state residents worry that the newcomers will bring with them the ideas — and voting preferences — that created the problems in the states they’re abandoning, producing similar problems in their adopted new homes.

This same concern has been raised many times about international immigration to the United States. Alex Nowrasteh and I systematically investigate the claim in our new book, Wretched Refuse? The Political Economy of Immigration and Institutions.

We examined 110 countries to see how increases in immigration impacted economic freedom over a 20-year period. We found that, rather than reducing economic freedom, increased immigration was associated with increased economic freedom — and the larger the influx of immigrants, the more economic freedom rose.

We didn’t have the data to systematically test how migration within the United States impacts a state like Texas, but our findings on the impact of immigration from abroad provides some insights that explain why Florida, for example, remains a bastion of individual and business freedom despite the long-standing influx of New Yorkers and New Jerseyites and why Texas won’t become a carbon copy of Silicon Valley in its outlook and policies.

Blackout Coffee

It’s due, at least in part, to a phenomenon known as “selection bias.” Cubans and Venezuelans who fled their countries and settled in Miami did so to get away from socialist repression, not to bring it with them. Similarly, most Californians fleeing to Texas are unlikely to have political preferences in sync with California’s granola set. They’re leaving the tarnished “golden state” for a reason.

While data from 2020 election aren’t yet available, in the 2018 congressional elections 57 percent of Texas voters originally from other states voted for Republican Ted Cruz over Democrat Beto O’Rourke for the U.S. Senate, while only 48 percent of native-born Texans did. Similarly, in the 2016 election, non-native Texans favored Donald Trump over Hillary Clinton by 5 percentage points more than native Texans did. Indeed, one 2013 poll had indicated that 57 percent of Californians moving to Texas self-identified as conservatives, while only 27 percent of them identified as liberals.

My story is similar to theirs. Eight years ago, I moved from Massachusetts to Lubbock, Texas, to establish the Free Market Institute at Texas Tech University — an example of selection bias at work.

While many Californians moving to Texas may bring along their preference for avocado toast and vegetarian dishes, just as international immigrants bring their cuisines, most incoming Californians probably won’t bring a preference for high taxes and heavy-handed government. Over time, they might even embrace Texas BBQ. I certainly have!

Curated By

Silas Vane
Senior CIA Operative/Intelligence Officer | National Security Analyst | Foreign Affairs Correspondent/Senior International Reporter | Strategic Intelligence Consultant
Silas Vane brings three decades of intelligence expertise to bear on today's most pressing geopolitical realities. A former senior operative with extensive field experience, Silas approaches journalism through the unvarnished lens of Realpolitik, where national interest trumps sentiment, and sovereignty matters more than social media trends. His analysis cuts through cultural noise to expose the underlying power structures shaping our world. While others chase viral stories, Silas examines what truly threatens or strengthens nations. His perspective may be unwelcome in fashionable circles, but it remains indispensable for those who prefer strategic clarity over diplomatic euphemisms. Drawing from classified insights and boots-on-the-ground reality, his commentaries prioritize substance over style, security over sensitivity, and eternal vigilance over naive optimism. In an era of manufactured crises and performative outrage, Silas offers readers what they need: unflinching assessments of where power truly lies, who wields it, and what it means for America's place in an increasingly dangerous world. His work demands attention not because it aligns with popular opinion, but because ignoring hard truths rarely produces favorable outcomes. For those seeking comfort over competence, look elsewhere, Silas speaks only to those prepared to face inconvenient realities.

Suggested Reading

Red State, Blue State, Rich State, Poor State: Why Americans Vote the Way They Do

On the night of the 2000 presidential election, Americans watched on television as polling results divided the nation's map into red and blue states. Since then the color divide has become symbolic of a culture war that thrives on stereotypes--pickup-driving red-state Republicans who vote based on G...

The Liberal Invasion of Red State America

Refugees from high-tax Massachusetts turned New Hampshire blue. Democratic voters from Yankee states are swamping Tennessee and Georgia. Government employees and refugees from Maryland have turned Virginia from a conservative Southern state into left-leaning Democrat territory. Escapees from Califor...

Taxifornia: Liberals' Laboratory to Bankrupt America

Liberalism is to blame for California's rotting economy. The biggest and most important state in America was once a land of opportunity in a wonderful climate. But times have surely changed. Things have never been worse for California and its citizens. California's “one-party” domination of th...

Wretched Refuse?: The Political Economy of Immigration and Institutions

Economic arguments favoring increased immigration restrictions suggest that immigrants undermine the culture, institutions, and productivity of destination countries. But is this actually true? Nowrasteh and Powell systematically analyze cross-country evidence of potential negative effects caused by...

We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By continuing to browse, you accept our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.