SPORTS

There are only two ways to control the chaos of college football

April 11th, 2025

The Nico Iamaleava situation isn’t the disease. It’s just the latest symptom of it.

College football has plunged into chaos. And it’s college football’s fault. After years of screwing the players, the chickens have come home to roost. And the rabbit now has the gun.

Coaches and administrators have, to date, largely reacted to the situation by pissing and/or moaning and/or (in the case of Nick Saban) quitting. The reality continues to be that there are only two ways out of this oversized corn maze.

One, embrace the notion that college football players are employees — and create a nationwide union.

Alison Training Health

ESPN’s Rece Davis recently suggested a “framework” that would address a situation like Iamaleava’s. That framework would come from a Collective Bargaining Agreement and, more importantly, from the antitrust exemption that a multi-employer bargaining unit would create.

Two, lobby Congress for an antitrust exemption. Multiple bills are currently pending that would overhaul the collegiate sports system. The better outcome (for the various institutions) would be to simply allow the NCAA and its member schools to set rules that would apply throughout the country. While it would be impossible to put the toothpaste entirely back in the tube at this point, the current problem flows directly from the fact that everything about the prior system of NCAA rules violated the federal antitrust laws. The only alternative to breaking down the walls was anarchy.

So it’s that simple. Welcome a union, or finagle a federal antitrust exemption. While either path will be complex and tricky, those are the only two choices for turning the current chaos into some sense of order.

Suggested Reading

Hail Mary: A Plan To Save College Football From The NCAA, NIL And Transfer Portal Chaos

HAIL MARY details a plan to save college football from the chaos caused by the NCAA’s inability to manage what has become a multi-billion dollar industry. The author proposes a 64-team Super League with four 16-team conferences, a 16-team playoff with all spots determined by results on the field and...

Against Football: One Fan's Reluctant Manifesto

"Against Football: One Fan's Reluctant Manifesto" by Steve Almond is a deeply personal and provocative exploration of America's obsession with football, a sport that the author himself once loved. Almond, a long-time fan of the game, confronts the moral and ethical dilemmas that have increasingly tr...

Saturday Millionaires: How Winning Football Builds Winning Colleges

Kristi Dosh’s Saturday Millionaires: How Winning Football Builds Winning Colleges is an in-depth exploration of the financial and institutional impact of college football programs on universities across the United States. As a sports business analyst, Dosh brings a data-driven and economic perspecti...

Billion-Dollar Ball: A Journey Through the Big-Money Culture of College Football

Over the past decade college football has not only doubled in size, but its elite programs have become a $2.5-billion-a-year entertainment business, with lavishly paid coaches, lucrative television deals, and corporate sponsors eager to slap their logos on everything from scoreboards to footballs an...

We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By continuing to browse, you accept our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.