ENVIRONMENT

The biggest myth about fossil fuels and dinosaurs, debunked by science

May 15th, 2023

Most oil reserves were formed between 65 and 252 million years ago. While this does overlap with the ‘dinosaur times’, oil is a marine sediment made of the remains of algae and plankton.

Skeletons of prehistoric reptiles such as plesiosaurs and ichthyosaurs (neither of which count as dinosaurs) have been found in the same geological layers as oil and they may have contaminated the oil deposit. But to say that oil is made from dinosaurs is like saying that bread is made from insects, just because the odd one occasionally falls into a flour mill.

Oil sediments formed in shallow seas that were teeming with life near the surface but stagnant and dead on the seabed. As dead plankton and microorganisms rained down, they buried the ones below them faster than they could decay. This trapped the organic matter in an oxygen-deprived layer that sank lower and lower as it was compressed from above.

Buffalo Jeans - 15% Off First Order

After 100 million years of this, the bottom layers were under several kilometres of clay and sand, and the heat and pressure at these depths converted the organic material into oil.

In contrast, a five-tonne plesiosaur falling dead to the seafloor would be very unlikely to remain undisturbed for long enough to be safely buried. Instead, it would be a temporary oasis for fish, crustaceans and worms that would quickly strip away the organic parts. We see this happening today when whale corpses fall to the seabed.

Coal is a much better place to find fossils; in fact, many plant and animal remains have been found preserved in coal seams. But coal deposits date from the Carboniferous era (359 to 299 million years ago), about 57 million years before the earliest dinosaurs. And even those animal fossils are embedded in, rather than contributing to, the coal deposit itself.

Curated By

Thomas Byrne
Religion and Ethics Reporter | Investigative Journalist | Editorial Writer/Columnist for Catholic Publications
Thomas writes with a steady hand in an unsteady age. In a climate driven by urgency and reaction, his work steps back to ask the questions that matter, and to follow them wherever they lead. Drawing on a disciplined, reflective approach, he examines political tensions, cultural shifts, and social challenges with an eye toward both principle and consequence. He resists the pull of easy conclusions, instead inviting readers into a deeper consideration of facts, context, and the human realities behind the headlines. His perspective is grounded in a respect for tradition, tempered by a recognition that every era must answer its own questions. Through careful reasoning and a measured tone, Thomas offers not just information, but clarity, encouraging a more thoughtful engagement with the world as it is, rather than as it is too often portrayed.

Suggested Reading

Dinosaurs: Profiles from a Lost World

Who isn’t fascinated by dinosaurs? These strange reptiles have awed us ever since their fossils were first identified as the bones of creatures from the distant past. For millions of years, dinosaurs ruled the prehistoric world. And now, millions of years after their mass extinction, they continue ...

The Moral Case for Fossil Fuels

For decades, environmentalists have told us that using fossil fuels is a self-destructive addiction that will destroy our planet. Yet at the same time, by every measure of human well-being, from life expectancy to clean water to climate safety, life has been getting better and better. How can this ...

The Rise and Fall of the Dinosaurs: A New History of Their Lost World

In this captivating narrative, Steve Brusatte, a young American paleontologist who has emerged as one of the foremost stars of the field—naming fifteen new species and leading groundbreaking scientific studies and fieldwork—masterfully tells the complete, surprising, and new history of the dinosaurs...

Fossil Future: Why Global Human Flourishing Requires More Oil, Coal, and Natural Gas--Not Less

For over a decade, philosopher and energy expert Alex Epstein has predicted that any negative impacts of fossil fuel use on our climate will be outweighed by the unique benefits of fossil fuels to human flourishing--including their unrivaled ability to provide low-cost, reliable energy to billions o...

We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By continuing to browse, you accept our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.