Synopsis
"On Heroism: McCain, Milley, Mattis, and the Cowardice of Donald Trump" by Jeffrey Goldberg is a compelling examination of the contrasting approaches to leadership and service exhibited by prominent military figures and former President Donald Trump. Through the lens of individuals like Senator John McCain, General Mark Milley, and General James Mattis, Goldberg explores what it means to be a hero, especially within the context of military service and public duty.
The book delves into the life and legacy of John McCain, who is portrayed as the epitome of sacrifice and honor. McCain's experience as a prisoner of war in Vietnam and his subsequent political career are highlighted as examples of resilience, patriotism, and a deep commitment to the principles of democracy. His story is contrasted sharply with Trump's dismissive attitude towards McCain's service, famously stating, "I like people who weren’t captured." This statement is used by Goldberg to underscore the fundamental differences in how Trump and McCain view service and sacrifice.
General Mark Milley and General James Mattis are also central figures in the narrative, depicted as leaders who have dedicated their lives to the defense of the nation and the upholding of its values. Both men are shown to struggle with the challenges of serving under Trump, particularly as they sought to maintain the integrity of the military while navigating the often chaotic and unorthodox directives from the White House. Goldberg highlights their internal conflicts, the decisions they had to make, and their ultimate refusal to compromise their principles, even at the cost of their careers.
In stark contrast to these figures, Trump is portrayed as embodying cowardice and a lack of respect for the institutions and individuals who have sacrificed for the country. Goldberg argues that Trump's disdain for the military and its leaders is rooted in a fundamental misunderstanding of what it means to serve others selflessly. The book suggests that Trump's behavior is indicative of a broader failure to appreciate the virtues of courage, loyalty, and duty, which are essential to true leadership.
Throughout "On Heroism," Goldberg not only tells the stories of these key figures but also offers a broader critique of the state of American leadership during Trump's presidency. He questions how a nation built on the ideals of heroism and sacrifice could elevate someone who seemingly embodies the opposite. The book serves as both a tribute to those who have exemplified true heroism in service to the country and a cautionary tale about the dangers of leadership devoid of these qualities.