Book

Left Out: Reds and America's Industrial Unions

2002

Synopsis

Left Out: Reds and America's Industrial Unions by Judith Stepan-Norris and Maurice Zeitlin provides a rigorous sociological and historical analysis of the influence of Communist Party (CP) members within the Congress of Industrial Organizations (CIO) during its formative years. The authors challenge the traditional Cold War narrative that viewed Communist labor leaders as mere puppets of Moscow whose political allegiances compromised the interests of their rank-and-file members. Instead, the book utilizes a massive dataset of union contracts and constitutional provisions to argue that "Red-led" unions were actually more effective, more democratic, and more committed to radical egalitarianism than their non-Communist counterparts.

The central thesis suggests that the presence of Communist leadership was a decisive factor in securing superior collective bargaining agreements. The authors demonstrate that these unions were more likely to win "pro-labor" contract clauses, such as those protecting against speed-ups and ensuring grievance procedures, while also pushing for broader social goals like racial and gender equality. By comparing the institutional outcomes of different CIO affiliates, the text posits that the revolutionary ideology of the CP members fueled a more militant and principled brand of unionism that successfully challenged the prerogatives of management.

Ultimately, the book explores the decline of this influence, specifically the mass expulsions of Communist-led unions from the CIO in the late 1940s. Stepan-Norris argues that this purge was not just a political housecleaning but a transformative event that shifted the American labor movement toward "business unionism." This transition, they contend, led to a more bureaucratic and less adversarial relationship with capital, which contributed to the long-term stagnation and eventual decline of organized labor’s power in the United States. By marginalizing the most dedicated and strategically capable organizers, the labor movement arguably lost its most effective weapon for systemic change.

Suggested Reading

Khomeini's Ghost: The Iranian Revolution and the Rise of Militant Islam

In February 1979, Ayatollah Ruhollah Khomeini returned to Tehran after nearly fifteen years in exile and received a hero's welcome. Just as the new world order sought to purge the communist ideologies of the Cold War, the religious doctrine of Islamic fundamentalism emerged to pose an even greater t...

The United Mine Workers of America: A Model of Industrial Solidarity?

Founded by white, Anglo-Saxon pick miners in 1890, the United Mine Workers of America had become by World War I the largest, most powerful, and in many ways the most progressive labor organization in the American Federation of Labor. Developing out of a conference commemorating the hundredth anniver...

We use cookies to improve your experience on our website. By continuing to browse, you accept our Cookie Policy and Privacy Policy.